This is a semi-cmprehensive list of paints and their variants across major paint lines and over time including Citadel, Coat D'Arms, Vallejo, Scale75, and Army Painter
List modified from this post on Dakka Dakka.
| Colour | New Citadel***** | Old Citadel | Coat D'arms*** | Vallejo Game Color | Vallejo Model Color | Scale 75 | Army Painter | Hex Code |
| White Scar | Skull White* | White (101) | Dead White (001) | White (951) | White Matt | Matt White (WP1102) | FFFFFF | |
| Ceramite White | Smelly Primer* | Grey Primer (141) | White Primer (002) | Foundation White (919) | FFFFFF | |||
| Kislev flesh | Pallid Flesh* | Flesh (213) | Pale Flesh (003) | Light Flesh (928) | Pale Skin Matt | Kobold Skin | EEC8C7 | |
| Bestigor Flesh | Elf Flesh* | Elven Flesh (123) | Elf Skintone (004) | Flat Flesh (955) | F7BD7B | |||
| Dorn yellow** | Bad Moon Yellow* | Dusky Yellow (146) | Bad Moon Yellow (005) | Lemon Yellow (952) | FFF700 | |||
| Flash Gitz Yellow | Sunburst Yellow* | Sun Yellow (103) | Sunblast Yellow (006) | Flat Yellow | Demonic Yelow (WP1107) | FFE700 | ||
| Yriel Yellow | Golden Yellow* | Golden Yellow (159) | Gold Yellow (007) | Golden Yellow (948) | Sol Yellow Matt | FFCE00 | ||
| Tallarn Sand | Desert Yellow* | Desert Yellow (063) | Dark Yellow (978) | Sahara Yellow Matt | Desert Yellow (WP1121) | 9C8855 | ||
| Jokaero Orange | Macharius Solar Orange* | Heavy Orange (152) | German Orange (805) | EE3823 | ||||
| Fire Dragon Bright | Fiery Orange * | Flame Orange (105) | Orange Fire (008) | Light Orange (911) | Prison Jumpsuit (WP1211 Zombiecide) | FF8552 | ||
| Troll Slayer Orange | Blazing Orange* | Burnt Orange (147) | Hot Orange (009) | Scarlet (817) | Mythical Orange (WP1442) | F46C2E | ||
| Mephiston Red | Mechrite Red* | Heavy Red (141) | Red (926) | Vampire Red (WP1460) | 991115 | |||
| Evil Sunz Scarlet | Blood Red* | Blood Red (104) | Bloody Red (010) | Vermillion (909) | Antares Red | Pure Red (WP1104) | C21920 | |
| Wild Rider Red | Mars Red (WP1436) | EB2E28 | ||||||
| Wazdakka Red | Red Gore* | Vampire Red (129) | Gory Red (011) | Cavalry Brown (982) | Indian Shadow | Dragon Red (WP1105) | 940008 | |
| Khorne Red | Scab Red* | Scarlett Red (012) | Carmine Red (908) | Deep Red Matt | Chaotic Red (WP1142) | 6A0002 | ||
| Emperor's Children | Tentacle Pink* | Shocking Pink (144) | Squid Pink (013) | Pink (958) | EF9CB5 | |||
| Screamer Pink | Warlock Purple* | Warlock Purple (157) | Warlord Purple (014) | Magenta (945) | Fuchsia Matt | 9C004A | ||
| Xereus Purple | Liche Purple* | Poison Purple (118) | Hexed Lichen (015) | Royal Purple (810) | Alien Purple (WP1128) | 5A005A | ||
| Naggaroth Night | Imperial Purple* | Amethest Purple (160) | Royal Purple (016) | Royal Purple (810) | 562F7E | |||
| Nauseating Blue * | Nauseous Blue (162) | Sick Blue (017) | Violet ** (960) | 412A7A | ||||
| Storm Blue * | Stormy Blue (018) | Blue (925) | 27357E | |||||
| Midnight Blue* | Night Blue (019) | Dark sea blue | 31 | |||||
| Kantor Blue | Regal Blue* | Royal Blue (110) | Imperial Blue (020) | Dark Prussian blue | Deep Blue (WP1116) | 08085A | ||
| Altdorf Guard Blue | Ultramarine Blue | Marine Blue (148) | Ultra Marine Blue (022) | Ultramarine (839) | Ultramarine Blue (WP1115) | 29397B | ||
| Macragge Blue | Mordian Blue* | Heavy Blue (143) | Prussian Blue (965) | Navy Blue Matt | 2D567C | |||
| Caledor Sky | Enchanted Blue* | Wizard Blue (114) | Magic Blue (021) | Dark Blue (930) | Crystal Blue | 31639C | ||
| Lothern Blue | Ice Blue | Ice Blue (095) | Azure ** (902)/ Deep Sky Blue | Sky Blue | Voidshield Blue (WP1452) | 6B9CCE | ||
| Teclis Blue | Lightning Bolt Blue * | High Elf Blue (117) | Electric Blue (023) | Sky Blue (961) | Electric Blue (WP1113) | 8BB9DD | ||
| Sotek Green | Hawk Turquoise | Aquamarine (132) | Falcon Turquoise (024) | Light Turquoise (840) | Adriatic Blue Matt | Hydra Turquoise (WP1141) | 006B5A | |
| Sybarite Green | Vile Green * | Foul Green (025) | Park Green Flat (969) | 82C59C | ||||
| Kabalite Green | Jade Green* | Jade Green** (158) | Jade Green (026) | Emerald (838) | 069B7D | |||
| Scaly Green * | Scurf/Scurvey Green (027) | Emerald (838) | 026B67 | |||||
| Caliban Green | Dark Angels Green* | Dark Elf Green (111) | Dark Green (028) | Deep Green (970) | Angel Green (WP1112) | 5221 | ||
| Warpstone Glow | Snot Green* | Bogey Green (121) | Sick Green (029) | Intermediate Green (891) | Irati Green | 106B21 | ||
| Warboss Green | Goblin Green* | Goblin Green (108) | Goblin Green (030) | Pastel Green (885) | Goblin Green (WP1109) | 63B521 | ||
| Elysian Green | Camo Green* | Camouflage Green (031) | Olive Green (967) | Ardenes Green Matt | A5A542 | |||
| Moot Green | Scorpion Green* | Scorpion Green (152) | Scorpy Green (032) | Light Green (942) | Spring Green | A5D610 | ||
| Bilious Green * | Livery Green (033) | Yellow Green ** (954) | A9D171 | |||||
| Castellan Green | Catachan Green* | Cayman Green (067) | Olive Grey (888) | Boreal Green Matt | 455440 | |||
| Waaagh! Flesh | Orkhide Shade* | Heavy Blackgreen (147) | Black Green (980) | Black | 3.84E+51 | |||
| Loren Forest | Knarloc Green* | Heavy Green (146) | Luftwaffe Ca. Green (823) | Army Green (WP1110) | 434F38 | |||
| Deathworld Forest | Gretchin Green* | Heavy Khaki (149) | Russian Uniform WW2 (70.924) | Venom Wyrm (WP1461) | 5D6732 | |||
| Straken Green | 628026 | |||||||
| Nurgling Green | Rotting Flesh* | Putrid Green (125) | Dead Flesh (035) | Green sky | Necrotic Flesh | 849B63 | ||
| Ushabti Bone | Bleached Bone* | Bone (112) | Bonewhite (034) | Buff (976) | Golden Skin Matt | Skeleton Bone (WP1125) | EFD9A8 | |
| Zandri Dust | Kommando Khaki* | Khaki (061) | G. Cam.Beige (821) | Thar Brown Matt | 9E915C | |||
| Pallid Wych Flesh | CDCEBE | |||||||
| Screaming Skull | Ivory (918) | White Sands Matt | F0F1CE | |||||
| Bronzed Flesh * | Tanned Flesh (115) | Bronze Flesh (036) | Dark Flesh (927) | F7944A | ||||
| Tau Light Ochre | Vomit Brown* | Bilious Brown (130) | Filthy Brown (037) | Beige Red ** | DE9408 | |||
| Ratskin Flesh | Dwarf Flesh* | Dwarven Flesh (124) | Dwarf Skin (041) | Brown Sand | Barbarian Flesh (WP1126) | F78C5A | ||
| Bugman's Glow | Tanned Flesh * | Tan (066) | Kalahari Orange Matt | Tanned Flesh (WP1127 ) | A95C3E | |||
| Leprous Brown* | Leprous Brown (156) | Scrofulous Brown (038) | Gold Brown (877) | D88E2D | ||||
| Zamesi Desert | Bubonic Brown* | Festering Brown (126) | Plague Brown (039) | Yellow Ochre (913) | Iroko Matt | C68400 | ||
| Balor Brown | Snakebite Leather* | Barbarian Leather (116) | Cobra Leather /Leather Brown (040) | Brown Sand (876) | 9C6B08 | |||
| Balor Brown | Tausept Ochre* | Heavy Ochre (150) | Ochre Brown (856) | 976F3C | ||||
| Skrag Brown | Vermin Brown* | Rat Brown (119) | Parasite Brown (042) | Orange Brown (981) | Mars Orange Matt | 843910 | ||
| Rhinox Hide | Scorched Brown* | Charred Brown (045) | Burnt Umber (941)** | Black Leather Matt | 390008 | |||
| Doombull Brown | Dark Flesh* | Dark Fleshtone (044) | Mahogany Brown (846) | 630808 | ||||
| Baneblade Brown | Khemri Brown* | Heavy Brown (153) | Green Brown | Arabic Shadow Matt | 7.05E+50 | |||
| Mournfang Brown | Bestial Brown* | Hairy Brown (120) | Beasty Brown (043) | Flat Brown (984) | 663300 | |||
| Mournfang Brown | Calthan Brown* | Heavy Siena (154) | Flat Brown (984) | 6D5044 | ||||
| XV-88 | Terracotta* | Terracotta (065) | 793721 | |||||
| Steel Legion Drab | Graveyard Earth* | Earth (062) | US field drab | Gobi Brown Matt | Leather Brown (WP1123) | 655138 | ||
| Karak Stone | Kommando Khaki* | Khaki (061) | German Cam. Beige WWII (821) | 9B8C7B | ||||
| Ulthuan grey | Ghostly Grey * | Ghost Grey (046) | Flat Aluminum (993) | C3C6CD | ||||
| Fenrisian Grey | Space Wolves Grey* | Lupin Grey (151) | Wolf Grey (047) | Pale Greyblue (907) | Bering Blue Matt | CEDEE7 | ||
| The Fang | Shadow Grey* | Shadow Grey (150) | Sombre Grey (048) | Oxford Blue (807) | Wolf Grey (WP1119) | 4E5067 | ||
| Administratum Grey | Fortress Grey* | Stonewall Grey (049) | Pale Grey Blue (907) | Nacar Matt | Ash Grey (WP1117) | B5B5B5 | ||
| Dawnstone | Codex Grey* | Cold Grey (050) | Basalt Grey (869) | Artic Blue Matt | Uniform Grey (WP1118) | 999999 | ||
| Mechanicus Standard Grey | Adeptus Battlegrey* | Heavy Grey ** | Russian Unif. (924) | 7C8286 | ||||
| Celestra Grey | Astronomicon Grey* | Heavy Bluegrey (144) | Pale Blue Grey (905) | 96A5A9 | ||||
| Abaddon Black | Chaos Black* | Black (102) | Chaos Black / Black (051) | Black (950) | Matt Black (WP1101) | 0 | ||
| Runefang Steel | Mithril Silver* | Enchanted Silver (106) | Mithril Silver / Silver (052) | Silver (997) | Shining Silver (WP1129) | B5B5BD | ||
| Ironbreaker | Chainmail* | Chainmail (109) | Chain Mail (053) | Natural Steel (864) | Plate Mail Metal (WP1130) | 7B737B | ||
| Leadbelcher | Boltgun Metal* | Gun Metal (142) | Gunmetal / Gunmetal Metal (054) | Gunmetal Grey (863) | Petroleum Grey | Machinegun Metal (WP1221) | 393939 | |
| Auric Armour Gold | Burnished Gold* | Glorious Gold (056) | Gold (996) | Dwarven Gold | Bright Gold (WP1231) | E7BD42 | ||
| Gehenna's Gold | Shining Gold* | Bright Gold (107) | Polished Gold (055) | Old Gold (878) | Elven Gold | Greedy Gold (WP1132) | CCCC33 | |
| Hashut Copper | Dwarf Bronze* | Dwarven Bronze (143) | Bright Bronze (057) | Bronze (998) | Weapon Bronze (WP1133) | 9C5221 | ||
| Runelord brass | Brazen Brass * | Brass (131) | Brassy Brass (058) | Brass (801) | Viking Gold | 735A21 | ||
| Brass scorpion | Beaten Copper * | Hammered Copper (059) | Copper (999) | 73372D | ||||
| Warplock Bronze | Tin Bitz* | Magic Metal (113) | Tinny Tin (060) | Necro Gold | 393121 | |||
| Black Ink * | Black Ink (94) | 0 | ||||||
| Dark Green Ink * | Green Ink (89) | 108473 | ||||||
| Flesh Wash * | Ink Wash - Flesh (133) | CE8C42 | ||||||
| Magenta Ink * | 513D3C | |||||||
| Purple Ink * | Violet Ink (87) | 842994 | ||||||
| Stormvermin Fur | Charadon Granite* | Heavy Charcoal (155) | German Grey (995) | Anthartic Grey Matt | 4D4A4A | |||
| Rakarth Flesh | Dheneb Stone* | Heavy Warmgrey **(148) | Drake Tooth (WP1417)? | B9ADA1 | ||||
| Daemonette Hide | Hormagaunt Purple* | Heavy Violet (142) | Violet (960) | Violet Blue Matt | 4F566C | |||
| Averland Sunset | Iyanden Darksun* | Heavy Goldbrown (151) | Goldbrown (877) | 9C8A53 | ||||
| Cadian Fleshtone | Tallarn Flesh* | Heavy Skintone (140) | Brown Rose | 8D736C | ||||
| Drakenhof Nightshade | Asurmen Blue Wash* | Blue Shade Wash (73207) | Blue Tone Ink (WP1139) | 2.73E+53 | ||||
| Carroburg Crimson | Baal Red Wash* | Red Shade Wash (73206) | Red Tone Ink (WP1138) | 630808 | ||||
| Nuln Oil | Badab Black Wash* | Black Wash (73201) | Dark Tone Ink (WP1136) | 0 | ||||
| Agrax Earthshade | Devlan Mud Wash* | Umber Shade Wash (73203) | Strong Tone Wash (WP1135) | 393121 | ||||
| Seraphim Sepia | Gryphonne Sepia Wash* | Sepia Wash (73200) | Soft Tone Ink (WP1134) | 843910 | ||||
| Druchii Violet | Leviathan Purple Wash* | **** Pale Grey Shade Wash (73202) | Purple Tone Ink (WP1140) | 842994 | ||||
| Reikland Fleshshade | Ogryn Flesh Wash* | Fleshtone Shade Wash (73204) | Flesh Wash (WP1143) | CE8C42 | ||||
| Biel-Tan Green | Green Wash | Green Tone Wash (WP1137) | 547757 | |||||
| Baharroth Blue Edge (Edge) | Toxic Mist (WP1437) | 59C1CE | ||||||
| Gauss Blaster Green (Edge) | 84C2A9 | |||||||
| Dorn Yellow (Edge) | FFF685 | |||||||
| Fulgrim Pink (Edge) | F5AECC | |||||||
| Flayed One Flesh (Edge) | CDC586 | |||||||
| Dechala Lilac (Edge) | Oozing Purple (WP1445) | B69FCD | ||||||
| Kreig Khaki (Edge) | Necrotic Flesh (WP1108) | BFBD82 | ||||||
| Blue Horror (Edge) | Gorgon Hide (WP1428) | A4BAD2 | ||||||
| Lugganath Orange (Edge) | Centuar Skin (WP1408) | F89E86 |
(*) discontinued,
(**) approximate,
(***) coat d'arms match the OLD citadel colours so there might be some difference. Shining gold has the most noticeable difference,
(****) P3 Paints did not really match very closely with the old GW range, but a detailed explanation of each paint can be found here: http://www.brushthralls.com/pre-painting-prep/color-theory-10p3.html
(*****) GW's new range matches with the old range are the matches claimed by GW. However, many of the paints do not match very closely at all and some mixing will be required to get close to the original colours. If you are trying to match old GW with new GW, you'd be better just getting Vallejo game color or coat d'arms for the closest match )
(color name) after testing does not match GW color (really far)
(******) 98-99% colour matches, colour difference is so minute it's very difficult to tell the difference when painting models side by side
(*******) 3rd-5th Edition Replicas, same 98-99% matching criteria